Nikki Lagouros

Herndon Downtown Lot: Comstock Ruling, Appeal and New Council

A Fairfax County Circuit Court judge ruled in September 2026 that the Town of Herndon is not entitled to take back its nearly 5-acre downtown site at Elden and Center Streets from developer Comstock, and the Town Council has voted to appeal. The lot has sat vacant since 2017, a mostly new Town Council takes office next year, and nothing is scheduled to be built there yet.

Fenced vacant lot beside older brick buildings, illustrating the vacant downtown Herndon VA redevelopment site
Photo: Haley Cao via Pexels (illustrative, not the Herndon site)

Quick summary

  • The site is the northeast quadrant of the Elden Street and Center Street intersection in downtown Herndon, nearly 5 acres, vacant since 2017 per WJLA.
  • In an opinion dated September 17, 2026, Judge Tania M.L. Saylor granted summary judgment to Comstock, finding the town “is not entitled to a reconveyance of the property.”
  • The Herndon Town Council voted unanimously in October to appeal to the Court of Appeals of Virginia.
  • In the November 3 election, only one incumbent council member on the ballot won, so a mostly new council will steer what comes next.

How the downtown lot went quiet

In 2017 the town signed a comprehensive agreement with Comstock to turn the town-owned block into a mixed-use project with apartments, an arts center, retail space and a parking garage. The town transferred the land to the developer, and the agreement gave the town a right to terminate the developer’s title under certain conditions.

A 2020 amendment changed that. According to the court, it gave Comstock the right to back out of the project without penalty if it did so by a certain date. Comstock withdrew from the project in 2024, and the town sued in 2025 to get the land back.

What the September ruling said

Both sides asked the judge to decide the case without a trial. In her September 17 opinion, Judge Saylor pointed to the 2020 amendment and to the December 2020 deed, which she wrote does not say the town keeps a right to reenter the property after the transfer. The result: Comstock keeps control of the site for now.

Mayor Keven LeBlanc said the town was “stunned and disappointed.” Comstock said it remains willing to work with town officials on a Class-A mixed-use project downtown. On October 5, town staff updated the council on the ruling, and the council voted unanimously to take the case to the Court of Appeals of Virginia.

A mostly new council takes over

Herndon voters filled six council seats on November 3, 2026. Based on unofficial results reported by FFXnow, Clark Hedrick was the only incumbent on the ballot to win, and five first-time candidates were elected. Mayor LeBlanc won a second term unopposed. Results are certified by the State Board of Elections by the first Monday of December.

Before the election, several candidates who went on to win signed a letter pledging to keep working to recover the property and to require enforceable deadlines in any future development deal. Setting a new vision for downtown is among the priorities newly elected members have named, alongside housing policy tied to the town’s comprehensive plan update for 2050.

What this means for Herndon homeowners

Day to day, very little changes yet. The lot stays as it is while the appeal plays out, and the rules for what can be built downtown are still being written. A realistic order of events is an appeal decision, a final answer on who controls the land, a planning process, and only then a developer and a construction schedule. Treat any opening year you hear as a guess.

If you own near downtown or the Herndon Metro station, this is worth watching because what goes on this block will shape the feel of the historic core for years. I did not find any published data tying this dispute to local home prices, so be wary of anyone who says they know the effect. Our Herndon development tracker follows projects around town, and our guide to historic homes in downtown Herndon covers the streets closest to the site.

Curious what your home is worth while all this plays out? You can get a Herndon home value estimate, or visit our Herndon area page for more local context.

Frequently asked questions

Who controls the downtown Herndon lot right now?

Comstock. A Fairfax County Circuit Court judge ruled on September 17, 2026 that the town is not entitled to have the property returned, so the developer keeps control while the town appeals.

Is Herndon appealing the Comstock ruling?

Yes. The Herndon Town Council voted unanimously in October 2026 to appeal to the Court of Appeals of Virginia.

Where is the downtown Herndon redevelopment site?

It is the nearly 5-acre block in the northeast quadrant of the Elden Street and Center Street intersection in downtown Herndon.

When will anything be built on the lot?

No construction date has been announced. The appeal, a decision on who controls the land, and planning approvals would all come first.

Sources

Details are current as of November 14, 2026. Election results are unofficial until certified. Check the Town of Herndon for updates on the appeal.

Ready to talk about your next move?

Call or text Nikki and her team for a straight answer on pricing, timing and next steps. No pressure and no obligation.

Text Me Now
Scroll to Top